Tag Archives: Islay

Caol Ila 12 Year

This is a very complex scotch and especially for an Islay scotch (in my opinion), compared to Lagavulin, Laphroaig, Ardbeg and others this has a much broader spectrum of flavors and is smoother than its fellow Islay scotches.

20151212_171416

The scent is smoky and sweet but mild.  The first flavor I get is malt followed by smoke.  In fact it initially tastes a little like Glenlivit 12 year or other Highland scotches for a second then the strong smoke fills your mouth.  As soon as you swallow a mouth full there is a sweet, fruity, floral taste that dominates.  It goes down smooth but leaves a spicy, smoky, and floral after taste.  This is one of the more interesting scotches I’ve tasted and I’m impressed with the complexity.  That is not what I typically go for.  If you read my blog you know I typically lean to the smoke and peat side.  Being an Islay scotch I expected that but the plethora of flavors is intriguing.  More so because they are all hidden in there.  They don’t come out at once.  To really appreciate this scotch you need to track the flavors in time.  Hold it in the front of your mouth for a few seconds, swish it around then swallow.  Each phase brings new flavors.

At 43% abv the price was $75, which is pricey for a 12 year but worth it for the flavor and complexity.  It’s in my price point for a good Islay, Lagavulin 16 year etc.  I would buy this again or keep a bottle in my collection for guests.

Copyright 2015, David R Bergman

Bruichladdich Port Charlotte

I am a little disappointed.  I had a bottle of Black Arts by Bruichladdich that was amazing.  I want another someday.  So I was very eager to try this, it has all my favorite features among which are being from Islay and being Peated, Heavily Peated.  If I compare this to Ardbeg they are about 80% similar but I appreciate Ardbeg a lot more after tasting this.

20151011_165741

The color is light amber and the odor is earthy, peat, smoky, very promising.

Hold a swig in the front of your mouth and you will get a burning peaty wood flavor.  But I was surprised at how sweet this was when I swallowed it.  The initial taste is very sweet, way too sweet for my taste.  It almost seems like they created a very artificial sweetness to balance the peat.  For those of us that like, smoke, peat and medicinal flavors this ruins it (at least for me).  It has a long aftertaste that is more peaty and smoky.  The finish is the best part, it is here that you get straight smoke and peat and for me the flavor of an intense Chinese medicinal herb tea.  That was a pleasant surprise.  All in all, 10 years old, 50% abv and about 65$, if I had to do it again I’d go for Ardbeg 10 year.  The sweetness is what killed it for me.

Copyright 2015 David R Bergman