Tag Archives: single malt

Talisker 10 year

Happy 2016!  It seems like just last year that I was ringing in 2015 with a Scotch reveiw, why change a good habit.  So here we go with Talisker 10 year.

20160101_172431

Years ago when I lived in Maryland I used to frequent a store there called The Perfect Pour.  It was a good store, great beer and wine selection.  They had a large collection of single malts there but the prices were unreliable.  One thing I always looked forward to was the small samplers are the check out.  Of course they had the 1oz Jack and Jim, but they also had a 3 piece sampler of Balvenie, 4 piece Ben Riach, and 3 piece Talisker.

At the time I was not very impressed with the Talisker, something about it didn’t sit well with me.  It was hard to put my finger on but after much consideration I described it as an Islay with a lot of spice in it, almost like hot salsa.  At first I was put out by the spice, but my tastes have somewhat changed over the years.  Especially with Dark Origins and Black Arts, both very spicy.

The aroma is light, sweet, and fruity, like a fruit pastry.  It reminded me of apricot Rugala.

Taste wise this is one of the spiciest scotches I’ve ever had.  It really fills up the sinuses!  Clears out congestion.  Other spicy scotches are more candy-like, cinnamon, ginger, etc.  Some are like black pepper or red pepper.  This is just pure heat and it just gets more intense after you finish it, like Wasabi or a mouth full of Horseradish at Passover.  The heat is strong enough to overwhelm other flavors, which is what I didn’t like about it the first time.  But there is clearly smoke and salty medicinal flavors here as well.  There is very pleasant after taste.

Takisker is not an Islay scotch but very similar in flavor.  It is the only distillery on Skye, west of the Northern Highlands.  Talisker 10 year is 45.8% abv and about $65.  I’m not sure if I’d buy Talisker 10 over Laphroaig or Ardbeg but I will try other members of the Talisker family.

Copyright 2016, David R Bergman

Bruichladdich Port Charlotte

I am a little disappointed.  I had a bottle of Black Arts by Bruichladdich that was amazing.  I want another someday.  So I was very eager to try this, it has all my favorite features among which are being from Islay and being Peated, Heavily Peated.  If I compare this to Ardbeg they are about 80% similar but I appreciate Ardbeg a lot more after tasting this.

20151011_165741

The color is light amber and the odor is earthy, peat, smoky, very promising.

Hold a swig in the front of your mouth and you will get a burning peaty wood flavor.  But I was surprised at how sweet this was when I swallowed it.  The initial taste is very sweet, way too sweet for my taste.  It almost seems like they created a very artificial sweetness to balance the peat.  For those of us that like, smoke, peat and medicinal flavors this ruins it (at least for me).  It has a long aftertaste that is more peaty and smoky.  The finish is the best part, it is here that you get straight smoke and peat and for me the flavor of an intense Chinese medicinal herb tea.  That was a pleasant surprise.  All in all, 10 years old, 50% abv and about 65$, if I had to do it again I’d go for Ardbeg 10 year.  The sweetness is what killed it for me.

Copyright 2015 David R Bergman

Dalmore King Edward III

A trip to the liquor store and a search for something new led to my discovery of Dalmore King Edward III.  Based on my research this contains a blend of various Dalmore casks some of which date back to 1990.

Dalmore2

The color is very red and the nose malty, nutty and creamy.  I’ve tried scotches before that claim to have a creamy odor or flavor and I’ve never been able to identify it until now.

When I first drink it I taste apricot, licorice, malt – baked goods, and a hint of vanilla.  The aftertaste is stronger than the first taste with a little smoke and black pepper.  The strongest flavors to me are the malts.  This scotch leaves a sting on the tongue and lips but goes down like water, no after burn in the throat.  It’s very smooth, one of the smoothest I’ve tasted.

I generally don’t gravitate to the malty, fruity, scotches but I’m always trying new things.  It’s a challenge to identify the flavors in the scotch and my tastes are changing with exposure to new things.  This was not a strong scotch.  Flavors were not bright or bold but more subdued.  The price was about $160 per bottle and 40% abv.

Copyright 2015 David R Bergman

Ardbeg Perpetuum

I’ll get to the point.  Ardbeg’s newest creation Perpetuum is consistent with their flavor profile.  Salty, briny, mild iodine and medicinal.  In my opinion it is similar to their 10 year in flavor.  Corryvreckan and Uigeadail are unique and Ardbog was a little too much, way too salty for me and I gave it a sort of negative review.  This one is somewhere between 10 year and Ardbog.  My main issue with it is that it isn’t unique enough to justify the 100$ price tag.  Ardbeg is usually stronger than the average scotch, this one is 47.4% abv.  It tastes great with or without ice but does not distinguish itself from the rest.  It isn’t bold enough or unique enough.  Sorry but they can’t all be good.  I’ll drink mine and enjoy it but I’d rather get Corryvreckan next time I have 100$ burning a hole in my pocket.

Copyright 2015 David R Bergman